SimpliSafe vs. ADT Home Security

SimpliSafe gives you more bang for your buck, but is ADT worth the splurge?

Best Value
SimpliSafe
SimpliSafe
4.5 out of 5 stars
4.5
Starting from
$19.99
/mo
Most Popular
ADT Shield
ADT
4.3 out of 5 stars
4.25
Starting from
$28.99
Brianne Sandorf
Nov 20, 2023
Icon Time To Read3 min read

When it comes to home security, SimpliSafe and ADT are practically opposites. SimpliSafe is the fun newcomer. It’s easygoing and flexible, but is it reliable? On the other hand, ADT is more like your dad. It’s older, it’s more experienced, and it’s gonna protect you—but you’ve gotta follow the house rules.

Guide to this SimpliSafe vs. ADT comparison:

SimpliSafe and ADT comparison
CompanySimpliSafeADT
Starting price$19.99–$29.99/mo.$28.99–$59.99/mo.
Installation typeDIYProfessional
Installation feeNoneVaries depending on package
Contract lengthNo contract36 mos.
Cancellation feeNone75% of remaining contract
Smart home supportLimitedYes*
Starter kit price$199.97N/A
Mobile app controlYes**Yes**
Learn more

* Smart home functions not supported by all monitoring plans. 

** Mobile app control not available with all monitoring plans.

Looking for a DIY home security system?
Heads Up

If you're looking for a home security system that you can install yourself, ADT's DIY offering allows you to self-monitor without contracts, installation fees, or cancellation fees.

Simplisafe hub and sensors

What we like about SimpliSafe

SimpliSafe is cheap—and way cheaper than ADT. If you want to secure your home but you don’t want to spend your life savings to do so, then this is the system for you. You’ll pay less for a SimpliSafe starter kit than what you did for your PlayStation 5.

Even the monitoring is cheap. Monitoring is the service that calls the police for you if your home catches fire or gets broken into while you’re away. SimpliSafe monitoring prices top out at $29.99 per month. That’s, like, five drinks from your local java joint. You can do it.

What we like about ADT

ADT Equipment

ADT is the old standard. It’s the best-known name in home security and for good reason—it’s been around for over 100 years, and it does everything for you. It’s professionally installed, so you don’t have to lift a finger. Plus, it has full smart home and security camera support (if you choose a plan that includes it).

With this system, you get the reliability of a big-name brand plus fancy new tech like smart lights, smart locks, and smart garage door openers. ADT even has an app called ADT Go that can tell you when your teenager leaves school (or sneaks off to their significant other’s house in the middle of the night).

SimpliSafe vs. ADT pros comparison

SimpliSafe pros:

  • Affordable equipment and monitoring
  • DIY installation
  • Online ordering

ADT pros:

  • Professional installation
  • Support for smart home devices
  • Reliable monitoring

What we don’t like about SimpliSafe

Simplisafe base station on dining room table

SimpliSafe might be new and affordable, but that comes with some downsides too. The system has faced some notable hacking incidents, which can be a huge hit to your peace of mind.

There haven’t been reports of any real-life houses being hacked by real-life burglars—just individual people trying to see if they could break the system. But still, it’s something to keep in mind.

Another thing is that SimpliSafe doesn't offer many smart home integrations. You get Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, but that's about it as far as third-party devices go.

What we don’t like about ADT

There’s no way around it: ADT is expensive. Really expensive. It’s the most expensive home security company we review. And it’s impossible to tell how much you’re going to pay for each device in your system because ADT doesn’t put its equipment prices anywhere.

Even we don’t know how much basic equipment costs through ADT, and we’ve got some connections on the inside.

You’ll get a reliable security system in the end, but don’t be surprised if you cringe when you see the monthly cost for your new ADT setup. You’ll also pay some extra fees SimpliSafe doesn’t charge, like an installation fee and a contract cancellation fee if you bail out of your agreement early.

SimpliSafe vs. ADT cons comparison

SimpliSafe cons:

  • Cybersecurity concerns
  • Limited smart home support

ADT cons:

  • Expensive monitoring
  • Unclear equipment pricing

Which one should you choose: SimpliSafe or ADT?

If you're a budgeter who doesn't mind getting their hands dirty, then go with SimpliSafe. (And we're kidding about the dirty hands part.) If you want the professionals to manage everything for you, and you don't mind paying quite a bit extra to get that, then go with ADT.

Methodology

So what’s our approach in comparing these completely different home security systems? We looked at:

  • Prices
  • Plans
  • Equipment
  • Cameras
  • Smart home support
  • Customer service

While some comparisons have a clear and obvious winner, this one was harder. The winner clearly depends on your home security needs—this isn’t a one-size-fits-all industry.

We would definitely recommend SimpliSafe to most people, though–its lower price and easy-to-use system meet many needs.

Brianne Sandorf
Written by
Brianne has a degree in English and creative writing from Westminster College and has spent 6+ years writing professional, research-based content. Before joining Reviews.org, she wrote safety and security content for ASecureLife.com. Her pieces and quotes are published across the web, including on MSN.com, Social Catfish, and Parents.com. Hobbies include wearing a seatbelt, wearing a life jacket, and keeping her arms and legs inside the ride at all times. Contact her at brianne@reviews.org.

Related Articles

A mom, dad, and two children sit on a couch and use a laptop together
Mediacom Internet Review: Customers Call It “Fast” and “Stable”
Mediacom is a cable internet service provider in the Midwest and Southeast that offers fast...
A young woman wearing glasses sits on the couch and surfs the internet on her laptop
Spectrum vs. AT&T Review
When it comes to Spectrum versus AT&T, AT&T is the better pick for most customers.
A man lies on a brown couch and shops online with his laptop
Cheapest Internet and Wi-Fi Providers
Fast internet is essential in the modern world, so you shouldn’t have to pay a...
A group of young men and women hold internet-enabled devices while sitting on a couch
Ting Internet Review
Ting Mobile started out as a small discount phone carrier. Now it’s in the home...