Go to Reviews.org AU Edition
Visible Wireless vs. Xfinity Mobile Cell Phone Plans Review
We compared Visible Wireless's and Xfinity Mobile's pricing and performance. High-data users should go with Visible, low-data users with Xfinity.
We've updated Xfinity Mobile's star rating from 3.5 to 4 to reflect a number of improvements they've made recently, including offering plans with unlimited 5G data and garnering best-in-class customer service scores.
We’re going to do an in-depth review of two mobile carriers that have been getting a lot of buzz recently: Xfinity Mobile and Visible Wireless. But we like to give you the short answer up front before we jump into the deep dive. So, which carrier is better?
Visible Wireless offers a powerful and affordable unlimited data plan that will be perfect for people who use their phones a lot. This plan is just $40, and it’s loaded with features.
Meanwhile, Xfinity Mobile has a few cheap limited data plans that will be perfect for folks who don’t stream, scroll, or Snapchat all day. But you have to be an existing Comcast customer to sign up.
How to choose a cell phone plan
We’ll talk about these carriers’ specific plans, pricing, and performance in a moment. But first, let’s go over what you want to look at when choosing a new cell phone plan.
- Data: So much of what we do on our phones, from TikTok to Google Maps, uses data. You want to make sure you have enough 4G LTE or 5G data to meet your needs.
- Price: There are tons of great looking deals out there right now. But be sure to read the fine print (some promotional prices end after a few months) and take a look at the competition before settling on a plan.
- Coverage: There are three major networks—AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon. All three companies run great networks, but one may offer better coverage in your area.
- Performance: There are many factors, from data speeds to mobile hotspots, that can affect the overall performance of your cell phone plan. Make sure you’re getting the most bang for your buck.
Visible vs. Xfinity plans and pricing
Xfinity Mobile offers a few different kinds of cell phone plans. Visible offers just one. Here are the pros and cons of each.
Visible’s unlimited data plan
Visible’s unlimited data plan doesn’t mess around. In fact, it’s one of the very best plans on the market right now, hands down. For $40 you’ll get unlimited talk, text, and data on Verizon’s awesome nationwide network. Plus you’ll get hotspot data, 5G network access, and other perks. Just take a look.
Visible unlimited data plan
This plan can compete with much pricier unlimited data plans and still hold its own. And it gets even cheaper when you add additional lines via Party Pay (more on that in the family plans section below).
So, what’s the drawback? The biggest problem is probably data throttling and deprioritization. Your 4G LTE data speeds will usually hover in the 5–12 Mbps range, which is slower than traditional phone plans from a company like AT&T or T-Mobile.
Xfinity’s By the Gig and Unlimited Data plans
We should make one thing clear from the start: only existing Comcast customers can get on Xfinity Mobile. If you’ve got Xfinity (Comcast) cable TV or home internet, then you’re good to go. If you don’t, then you’ll need to sign up before you’re eligible.
If you’re able to sign up, Xfinity Mobile offers more options than Visible Wireless. You can go for an unlimited data plan for $45 a month, or you can get a more flexible By the Gig plan. Here’s a look at these options side by side.
Xfinity Mobile cell phone plans
By the Gig
As you can see, Xfinity’s By the Gig plans start cheap. $15 a month will get you unlimited talk, text, and 1 GB. If you don’t use a ton of data that’s an unbeatable price. Plus, this plan gives you access to millions of Xfinity-owned Wi-Fi hotspots throughout the country. When you’re connected to one of these hotspots, you won’t drain your limited data.
There are three starting options for your By the Gig plan: 1 GB, 3 GB, and 10 GB. For each GB that you use over that starting amount, you’ll be charged an extra $15. That can add up pretty fast, so if you’re a heavy data user, it’s best to just get an unlimited data plan.
Xfinity’s unlimited data option is a pretty great deal. Much like Visible’s unlimited plan, this one will get you unlimited talk, text, and data. You’ll get hotspot data and 5G, too.
This plan has drawbacks similar to Visible’s, too. Your download speeds will be capped at 5–12 Mbps, and users of 20 GB or more of data could see their speeds go even lower. Your hotspot data speeds will be capped at 600 Kbps and your video streaming will be capped at 480p resolution.
At $45, it’s a lot cheaper than many other unlimited plans. But it’s not cheaper than Visible’s. So, if we have to choose an outright winner in the unlimited data plan category, we’d definitely choose Visible.
Visible vs. Xfinity family plans
Opting for a family plan can lower your cell phone bill drastically and make it easier to manage payments on multiple lines. Both Xfinity and Visible allow you to bundle multiple lines into a single account, but we’ll be honest up front here: Visible offers a way better deal.
Just check out this comparison between three unlimited data lines on Visible and three unlimited data lines on Xfinity.
Here’s a closer look at how family plans work on each of these carriers.
Visible Wireless family plan
Visible Wireless calls its family plans Party Pay. This makes sense because you can bundle up with anyone, not just family. You can add your co-workers, roommates, friends, or literally anyone else to your plan. Plus, each person can manage and pay their bill separately.
But the biggest perk to going with Party Pay is the cost savings. Each line you add—up to four lines total—will give you a steeper discount. Once you reach four lines your bill will be just $100. That’s $25 a line for unlimited talk, text, and data! That’s one of the best deals in the whole industry.
Xfinity family plans
As we mentioned above, Xfinity does allow you to add lines to your account, but it doesn’t actually give you a discount for doing so.
When you add lines to a By the Gig plan all of the lines will share the same pool of data. This can be convenient for families that don’t use a ton of data. But you have to be careful. If your daughter spends too many hours scrolling through Instagram, you might end up with an outrageous bill at the end of the month.
You can also add unlimited data lines to your plan. But nothing remarkable happens when you do. The only advantage is that you can pay for all of the lines with one simple bill.
Visible vs. Xfinity coverage
Both Xfinity and Visible are what we call mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs). That means that these companies don’t actually own and operate their own mobile network towers. Instead, they lease bandwidth from another company.
Both Visible and Xfinity use Verizon’s network. So you’ll get basically the same coverage with either one. This is great news, because Verizon operates the best network in the country. Just check out this coverage map.
Verizon coverage map
Verizon’s data speeds are also pretty great. Based on our data from over 100,000 wireless customers, Verizon has the second fastest data download speeds in the industry.
Now that Verizon is rapidly rolling out its 5G network, customers should see even better data speeds.
Visible vs. Xfinity customer service
Smaller phone carriers like Visible and Xfinity aren’t really known for their amazing customer service, and there isn’t much data to help us evaluate which one is better.
But if we compare each company’s customer service apps, we can see that Visible Wireless’s app has a 3.4-star rating on the Apple App Store, while Xfinity Mobile has an impressive a 4.8-star rating. Sometimes app ratings are misleading because the reviewers may be responding to bugs or flaws in the software, not necessarily a bad customer service experience. But these days, putting out a buggy app is bad customer service.
Recap: Which carrier is right for you?
We took a detailed look at everything these two companies have to offer. But here’s a quick recap to refresh your memory before you make a final decision.
- Plans: Visible’s unlimited data plan is an amazing powerhouse that gets you everything you could want for just $40 a month. Xfinity’s unlimited plan is a bit pricier without any obvious advantages. But lower-data users will be happy with Xfinity’s By the Gig plan.
- Family plans: When you add lines to your Visible account, your price goes down. You can get an unlimited data line for as little as $25 with Party Pay. Unfortunately, Xfinity’s family plans are not so impressive. The company doesn’t offer any family plan discounts.
- Coverage and performance: Both Visible and Xfinity are on Verizon’s network. Also, both companies are MVNOs that can have their data speeds deprioritized. So, performance wise, these two carriers are basically the same.
We take our reviews seriously, which is why we look at every carrier we evaluate from multiple angles, including price, features, coverage, and more. We utilize our own proprietary data from over 100,000 customers to figure out which companies offer the best performance, so you can figure out which carrier is best for you.